Week 9: Favorites Rule the Weekend—Except in New England
Week 9 delivered 15 games and a remarkably lopsided favorite record: favorites went 14-1. The prediction market’s average Brier score was 0.1166, better than the 0.2500 baseline. There were no ties.
That strong overall mark came with one glaring miss: Green Bay beating New England 45-27 despite the market making the Patriots the favorite.
Market Accuracy by Week
FOOTBALLBLOGGER / NFL MARKET ACCURACY
===============================================
Average Brier score (LOWER IS BETTER)
Each # represents approximately 0.01 Brier points
WEEK BRIER GAMES CHART
-----------------------------------------------
3 0.2517 16 #########################
4 0.2172 16 ######################
5 0.2236 14 ######################
6 0.2612 14 ##########################
7 0.2272 14 #######################
8 0.1788 14 ##################
9 0.1166 15 ############ <-- CURRENT
LATEST VS PREVIOUS: IMPROVED (-0.0622)
-----------------------------------------------
50/50 BASELINE: 0.2500
===============================================Best Call
The cleanest prediction came in Kansas City. The market gave the Chiefs an 80.5% chance against the Jets, and Kansas City handled business with a 35-12 victory.
- Prediction: KC at 80.5%
- Final score: NYJ 12, KC 35
- Brier score: 0.0361
That was the week’s lowest Brier score. Jacksonville’s 33-10 win at Baltimore was another strong call, with the Jaguars carrying a 77.5% market probability and producing a 0.0506 Brier score.
Biggest Miss
The market’s worst result came in Green Bay’s visit to New England. The Patriots were priced as a 61.5% favorite, but the Packers won convincingly, 45-27.
- Prediction: NE at 61.5%
- Final score: GB 45, NE 27
- Brier score: 0.3782
It was a surprising result, but one upset does not prove the original probability was unreasonable. A 61.5% forecast still leaves plenty of room for the other team to win.
Quarter Kelly
The original fictional Quarter Kelly strategy stayed on the sidelines this week. It started week 9 with $153.44 and finished at $153.44.
- Wagers: 0
- Record: 0-0
- Weekly profit/loss: $0.00
- Weekly return: 0.00%
All 15 games had usable 24-hour snapshots, but every game fell below the strategy’s five-percentage-point entry threshold. That suggests the fixed threshold was cautious this week, though more wagers would not automatically have been better.
Since the experiment began with $160.00, the original strategy now has:
- Current bankroll: $153.44
- Overall profit/loss: -$6.56
- Overall return: -4.10%
The walk-forward model used only earlier completed weeks and 24-hour snapshots, with historical calibration adjustments, quarter Kelly sizing, and a 10% bankroll cap. Weeks 3 and 4 were training only; Week 5 was the first test week. No real money was wagered.
Quarter Kelly 2.5% (Retrospective Comparison)
The 2.5% version is a RETROSPECTIVE historical comparison introduced later, not a prospectively tracked strategy. It uses the same walk-forward model and quarter Kelly sizing but keeps a separate bankroll.
This lower-threshold version found one eligible wager: Carolina against Denver. The model’s estimated probability for Carolina was 45.63%, compared with an assumed 42.5% price. Carolina lost, while Denver won 26-21.
- Starting bankroll: $148.78
- Wagers: 1
- Record: 0-1
- Amount wagered: $2.03
- Weekly profit/loss: -$2.03
- Ending bankroll: $146.75
- Weekly return: -1.36%
From the experiment’s original $160.00 bankroll:
- Overall profit/loss: -$13.25
- Overall return: -8.28%
This one-week comparison does not establish that either entry threshold is better.
Bet the House
The fictional Bet the House benchmark divides the carried-forward bankroll equally among eligible favorites, using the final market midpoint as the assumed price. It began with $10 per game in Week 3.
- Starting bankroll: $122.22
- Wagers: 15
- Record: 14-1
- Amount wagered: $122.22
- Weekly profit/loss: $43.61
- Ending bankroll: $165.83
- Weekly return: 35.68%
The lone loss was the Patriots against Green Bay, but the other 14 favorites won, producing a huge week.
Since the original $160.00 bankroll:
- Overall profit/loss: $5.83
- Overall return: 3.64%
What We Learned This Week
- The market had an excellent results week, with a 0.1166 Brier score and 14 favorite wins.
- The five-point Quarter Kelly threshold produced no bets, while the retrospective 2.5% version made one losing wager.
- Bet the House benefited heavily from the favorite-heavy schedule, but one week is not evidence of lasting profitability or predictive skill.
All betting described here is fictional. Midpoint prices may not be executable, fees are excluded, and this is not betting advice.