Week 10: Favorites Held Firm—Mostly
Week 10 brought 14 completed games, with favorites finishing 10-4. The market’s average Brier score was 0.1835, better than the 0.2500 baseline. There were no ties, so all 14 games counted in the binary results.
The headline result: the market got most favorites right, though a few road upsets kept the week from being spotless.
Market Accuracy by Week
FOOTBALLBLOGGER / NFL MARKET ACCURACY
===============================================
Average Brier score (LOWER IS BETTER)
Each # represents approximately 0.01 Brier points
WEEK BRIER GAMES CHART
-----------------------------------------------
3 0.2517 16 #########################
4 0.2172 16 ######################
5 0.2236 14 ######################
6 0.2612 14 ##########################
7 0.2272 14 #######################
8 0.1788 14 ##################
9 0.1166 15 ############
10 0.1835 14 ################## <-- CURRENT
LATEST VS PREVIOUS: WORSENED (+0.0669)
-----------------------------------------------
50/50 BASELINE: 0.2500
===============================================Best Call
The market’s strongest prediction was Jacksonville at Tennessee. JAX was given an 83.5% chance to win and delivered, beating TEN 40-23.
- Prediction: JAX at 83.5%
- Final score: JAX 40, TEN 23
- Brier score: 0.0272
That was a convincing result and the week’s cleanest call.
Biggest Miss
The largest miss came in Los Angeles’ visit to Baltimore. The market gave BAL a 67.5% chance, but LAC won 23-20.
- Prediction: BAL at 67.5%
- Final score: LAC 23, BAL 20
- Brier score: 0.4489
A surprising result does not necessarily mean the original probability was unreasonable. A 67.5% forecast still leaves plenty of room for the other team to win; it simply failed to happen this time.
Quarter Kelly
The original Quarter Kelly strategy stayed on the sidelines again. It began the week with $153.44 and ended with $153.44.
- Wagers: 0
- Record: 0-0
- Amount wagered: $0.00
- Weekly profit/loss: $0.00
- Weekly return: 0.00%
All 14 games were examined. None cleared the strategy’s five-percentage-point entry threshold, and no games were excluded because of missing 24-hour snapshots. The entry threshold may be overly cautious in some weeks, but more bets would not automatically be better.
This was a WALK_FORWARD_HISTORICAL test week, using only earlier completed weeks and 24-hour snapshots. Weeks 3 and 4 were training only, and Week 5 was the first test week. The model uses historical calibration adjustments, quarter Kelly sizing, and a 10% bankroll cap. These results do not establish profitability or predictive skill.
Since the experiment began, the original Quarter Kelly strategy has moved from $160.00 to $153.44:
- Overall profit/loss: -$6.56
- Overall return: -4.10%
Quarter Kelly 2.5% (Retrospective Comparison)
The 2.5% version is a RETROSPECTIVE historical comparison introduced later, not a prospectively tracked strategy. It uses the same walk-forward model and quarter Kelly sizing, but a lower entry threshold and a separate bankroll.
It placed six wagers and went 4-2:
- Starting bankroll: $146.75
- Amount wagered: $23.26
- Weekly profit/loss: +$0.03
- Ending bankroll: $146.78
- Weekly return: 0.02%
The wins included KC, IND, SF, and CIN. The losses were HOU and BAL. Since the experiment began, this separate comparison stands at:
- Original starting bankroll: $160.00
- Current ending bankroll: $146.78
- Overall profit/loss: -$13.22
- Overall return: -8.26%
That lower threshold should not be called better based on hindsight.
Bet the House
Bet the House divides the carried-forward bankroll equally among eligible favorites, using the final permanent snapshot midpoint as the assumed price. The experiment began with $160.00 bankroll in Week 3, divided equally among eligible favorites.
This week, it wagered on all 14 favorites and went 10-4:
- Starting bankroll: $165.83
- Amount wagered: $165.83
- Weekly profit/loss: +$10.82
- Ending bankroll: $176.65
- Weekly return: 6.52%
The losses included HOU, GB, BAL, and NYG. Wins such as DET, CAR, and BUF helped produce the strong weekly result.
Overall, Bet the House has grown from $160.00 to $176.65:
- Overall profit/loss: +$16.65
- Overall return: 10.41%
What We Learned This Week
- The market’s 0.1835 Brier score beat the 0.2500 baseline, with 10 of 14 favorites winning.
- The original Quarter Kelly rules were too cautious to place a wager, while the retrospective 2.5% version found six qualifying games.
- Bet the House had the best weekly result, but one week—and fictional midpoint prices without fees—cannot establish future profitability.
All wagers are fictional, midpoint prices may not be executable, and this experiment is not betting advice.